Constructive convergence, appropriation, inculturation, syncretism, and multiple religious belonging posted on november 3, 2012 november 2, 2012 by hans gustafson nicholas black elk 18661950, the oglala lakota visionary and son of crazy horses cousin, has been the subject of both debate and inspiration. Arguing from a postcolonial perspective, author damien costello. In their own terms, the sioux have lost the sacred hoop of their nation. This raised public awareness for the book, and had an effect on the american indian movement aim.
Neihardt, an american poet and writer, who relates the story of black elk, an oglala lakota medicine man. Black elk, the native american holy man, is known to millions of readers around the world from his 1932 testimonial black elk speaks. Black elk speaks did not become popular right away, but in 1972, john g. Critical essays cultural displacement in black elk speaks black elk speaks depicts the tragedy of a culture that can no longer support its traditional ideals. In this interview, neihardt talked about his relationship with black elk and the book on his life.
Like his father before him, black elk would become a warrior, as well as a medicine man or. But they did not lose it through a lack of faith or other internal weakness. Reviewing black elks offering the pipe prayer, i see many elements that ive seen in the temazcales that my mexican brothers and sisters have invited me to attend. Adapted by the poet john neihardt from a series of interviews, it is one of the most widely read and admired works of american indian literature. Neihardts book, black elk speaks, is one of the great religious books written on the american continent. Nicholas black elk, a holy man of the oglala sioux, came into the world in wyoming before it was wyoming, and died in the village of manderson, on the pine ridge indian reservation, in south. The book is long 600 pages and occasionally meanders, but it always does so with a purpose, such as when the author breaks away from black elks story to describe the conditions in indian. Neihardt from a series of interviews with black elk and other elders at the pine ridge reservation in south dakota, black elk speaks is one of the most widely read and admired works of. Black elk and book culture journal of the american. Black elk s account of the seven rites of the oglala sioux. The universe is circles within circles, and everything is one.
Neihardt, author of black elk speaks, interviewed black elk with an agenda and cultural bias in the context of extreme lakota poverty. However, the book has come under fire for what critics describe as inaccurate representations of lakota culture and beliefs. Bishop robert gruss is the executive director for the project and the diocese of rapid city will hold the. Black elk worked with john neihardt to give a firsthand account of his experiences and that of the lakota people. Black elk spoke in lakota and black elk s son, ben black elk, who was present during the talks, translated his fathers words into english. He brilliantly frames it with an incisive discussion of the creation of john neihardts 1932 astoldto book, black elk speaks. He has produced a major contribution to native american history. Later, anthropologist joseph epes brown interviewed black elk about lakota religious traditions for his book the sacred pipe 1953. This study of black elk, the oglala lakota subject of the bestselling black elk speaks, challenges the assumptions of many scholars both those who claim that black elk was a lakota holy man first and foremost and those who maintain that he abandoned his lakota tradition after converting to catholicism.
However, neihardts editing and his daughters transcription of black elk s words, as well as black elk s sons original spoken translation, raise questions about the narratives authenticity. Through black elk s life, as represented in this book, readers have assumed to have gained an authentic picture of impor. Black elk and book culture 89 ii since 1932 black elk speaks has steadily grown in popularity throughout the world and has achieved the status of a classic in its depiction of lakota traditional lifeways. The book strained black elk s relationship with the jesuits, and he subsequently worked at the duhamel sioux pageant, demonstrating traditional rituals. The epic life story of the native american holy man who has inspired millions around the world black elk, the native american holy man, is known to millions of readers around the world from his 1932 testimonial, black elk speaks. Book summary black elk speaks, a personal narrative, has the characteristics of several genres. Black elk was born in 1863 on the little powder river, in what is now wyoming. Black elk speaks greed is a large part of the american culture whether we realize it as a society or not.
Jackson digs into native american culture and what it meant for black elk to be a holy man, especially in light of his 1904 conversion to catholicism. I have learned a great deal from their ceremonies, and they have helped me better understand many of the concepts in the book and other literature from the historians, writers. However, neihardts editing and his daughters transcription of black elks words, as well as black elks sons original spoken translation, raise questions about the narratives authenticity. Though neihardt is the books author, the book is based on a conversation between black elk and neihardt and is presented as a transcript of black elks words, though neihardt made. Publishers weekly now readers can rediscover the real black elk and the wise, haunted book that bears his name. Nicholas black elk 18661950, the oglala lakota visionary and son of crazy horses cousin, has been the subject of both debate and inspiration. Arnold is assistant professor of american religions at syracuse university, syracuse, ny 2441170. Neihardt recoreded black elks experiences and insights in his book black elk speaks.
Black elk wrote black elk speaks which describes indian religion and culture as well as the struggles of tribes from 1863 to the massacre at wounded knee in 1890. Costello provides a very detailed look into the life of black elk and the lakota, as well as at the point where christianity meets american indian cultures. Comparison of black elk speaks and bury my heart at wounded knee beginning hundreds of years ago, native americans experienced an invasion. In a field where so much that is written is either banal or so prohibitively academic that nonspecialists can find no benefit in reading the books, costellos book is an oasis in a desert of dry texts. Not only has it introduced lakota religious concepts to nonindians, it has reintroduced countless indian young people to their roots, whether or. Black elk speaks is arguably the single most widely read book in the vast. Let every step you take upon the earth be as a prayer. Being the life story of a holy man of the oglala sioux. Black elk wanted to preserve his visions and the lifestylesculture of his people that was gone. Perpetrated first by european explorers, then conquerors, and, finally, colonists, the first people to inhabit the americas experienced a devastation of their land, culture, and dignity from people who. Both works are touched with a certain sadness, that of a man. As a little boy, black elk witnessed his village being invaded by wasichus, a term that. Adapted by the poet john neihardt from a series of interviews, it is one of the most widely read and admired works of.
Neihardt, an american poet and writer, who relates. In 1944 neihardt interviewed black elk for when the tree flowered 1951. Colonialism and lakota catholicism faith and culture. Here is the epic life story of the native american holy man who has inspired millions around the world.
When the two men met, black elk recognized that neihardt was a sympathetic. Black elk spoke about her great grandfather, his impact on u. My father was a medicine man and was brother to several medicine men. One wanted to write a novel, the other, an anthropological record of siouxan religion, culture and life style. Black elk article about black elk by the free dictionary. The book strained black elks relationship with the jesuits, and he subsequently worked at the duhamel sioux pageant, demonstrating traditional rituals. Black elk, the native american holy man, is known to millions of readers around the world from his 1932 testimonial, black elk speaks.
Neihardt, an indian boy then a warrior, and holy man describes the life his people had in the lands that belonged to them that were seized by invaders. Black elk was an old man even at the earliest interview date, and had been exposed for many years to catholic teachings, which he seemed to accept, with certain revisions to suit his lakota heritage, culture and religion much as native peoples around the world have done, especially in mexico and the phillipines, and maybe haiti as well. Many countries around the world view the united states as a selfish country that does what it wants on a global scale, and does not share or allocate its predominate wealth. Neihardt made notes during these talks which he later used as the basis for his book. Neihardts influential black elk speaks 1931, which explored the life of lakota spiritual leader nicholas black elk 18631950, was accepted as the last word on the lakota. Colonialism and lakota catholicism is extremely wellwritten. Black elk speaks in the book black elk speaks, being the life story of a holy man of the oglala sioux as told through john g. Encyclopedia of the great plains black elk, nicholas.
Ian frazier on nicholas black elk, a holy man of the oglala sioux who. Black elks journey toward sainthood, the company is tracing black elks life from his lakota culture to his 1904 baptism and tireless work evangelizing others. Neihardt paid black elk enough to support six or seven lakota families and promised him half the profits of the book and a possible movie deal. Neihardt was interviewed on television by talk show host dick cavett. It is also an introduction into sioux culture and especially into their spirituality and mysticism. Black elk spoke in lakota and black elks son, ben black elk, who was present during the talks, translated his fathers words into english. Since the 1970s the book black elk speaks has become an important source for studying native spirituality, sparking a renewal of interest in native religions. The life of an american visionary is an uneven, ultimately worthwhile book that chronicles the experiences and times of a briefly celebrated oglala lakota medicine man black elk.